The Unlucky Poker Player
Read Time: 5 Minutes

Read Time: 5 Minutes
I’m writing this from 30,000 feet, waving goodbye to the Portomaso Casino in Malta, where I finished 17th out of 1,000+ players in the Main Event.

As always, I learned a lot, yet there’s still much to learn. One of my takeaways is how our perspective shapes our reality, perhaps more than reality itself.
Deep in the event, a new player gets moved to our table. He comes out blasting like a cannon. Every time someone raises his big blind, he instantly moves all-in and steals the pot.
This goes on for four orbits before he is finally called, only to double when his kings hold against jacks. Magic.
With his newly accumulated chips, Mr. Invincible goes on a tear. He’s laughing, filming and his pumping up his rail. Everything goes his way… until it doesn’t.
A bluff goes awry and he loses the pot. Then he takes a bad beat. Another player wakes up with aces.
His view suddenly flips. It’s a 180 shift, the likes of which we only see in politics and poker.
I observe patiently as people bust, waiting for my moment. I am short stacked, crippled by several all-ins which didn’t go my way earlier in the day.
When the same player opens in late position, I look down at Ace-King and move in. He deliberates before calling with King-Jack.
A look of disgust comes over him when he sees that he’s dominated.
That all changes when a Jack hits the flop. He smashes the table with his fist in celebration and lets out a commanding howl.
The turn brings a Ten, giving me a glimmer of hope. He shoots a hostile stare toward the dealer. “Don’t you dare.”
The Queen comes. It almost had to given the spectacle.
He’s sickened. Like, truly miserable. He curses under his breath and goes on a tirade for the next 15 minutes, begrudging his luck with the typical “bad beat” complaints we’ve all heard ad nauseum.
The meltdown is so complete that he busts shortly after, ejecting himself like a pilot in a fighter jet, only forgetting that it would have been easier to land the plane safely, and that he had no parachute.
I share more about the story on YouTube, X and Instagram.
What stood out to me was that nothing changed from the moment he made his decision to the final card being dealt, except the arbitrary window he used to measure his luck.
After all, he got it all in behind and lost, just like he was expected to. Yet rather than questioning his marginal call, he blamed the dealer, the deck, God, the Devil – everyone but himself.
But for what exactly?
If instead of resetting his expectation on the turn of every card, had he closed his eyes for 20 seconds and opened them on the river, he probably would have felt nothing.
What changed wasn’t his expected value but his expectation.
The harsh truth is this is all self-inflicted. I’m not judging him, because I’ve been there more times than anyone, and I find it requires ongoing vigilance to overcome.
We must resist the urge to arbitrarily define the window of measurement to fit our biases about how lucky we are. Second, avoid setting an impossible expectation such as we deserve to win just because we’re a favorite.
This is a recipe for disappointment.
We can rig the game any way we want. Most rig it against themselves. They arbitrarily shorten the time window of measurement so that luck becomes the Villain and the “bad beats” are happening to them.
But what if we enlarge the window?
Instead of losing after flopping top pair to a backdoor straight, what if the story was, “I lost a standard all-in with King-Jack to Ace-King?”
Same hand. Same odds when the bet was made. Completely different story.
We can, of course, zoom out further. He may have been on the wrong side on the last hand, but he was lucky in the aggregate.
Reshoving four times in a row, only to get 3 folds and then double with kings to jacks is a series of very fortunate events.
Every all-in assumes a certain amount of risk, and all four of them transpired in his favor to get him where was. Instead of viewing this one unfortunate runout as part of his overall fortunate distribution, he isolated a single unfavorable hand while completely forgetting about the rest.
This level of mental gymnastics is all too common. I believe it’s in part because we’re hardwired to remember bad beats more than we recall favorable ones. The pain of losing is usually far greater than the joy of winning.
When we’re all in and ahead, we expect to win. When those expectations aren’t met we feel intense pain. On the other hand, when all-in as a favorite and hold, we win as we fully expected to, so we often feel little.
This emotional asymmetry is another recipe for disappointment.
A broader, more holistic perspective has helped me during the inevitable challenges I’ve faced at the poker table.
An exercise I use when evaluating luck is to zoom out and force myself to look at the big picture. I don’t always get this right but it’s something I aspire to.
For example, I can argue I was unlucky to bust in 17th after losing 3 all-ins in a row. And that would be a true statement.
However, a more complete perspective is to acknowledge I was lucky to get that deep because I won other all-ins earlier in the tournament.
Even if I was never all-in, as sometimes happens, I surely had many hands which went my way. This ‘unseen’ luck is hard to quantify causing many to overlook it.
It can be as simple as a river card that doesn’t complete the flush, allowing me to win the pot, or a blank which allows me to value bet and win more chips.
These innocuous hands that often go completely unnoticed are actually part of my “lucky” distribution.
A fascinating observation after speaking to thousands of players over the past 20 years is the average poker player thinks they are unlucky. Of course, this cannot be true because some players must be luckier than average.
However, this misses the broader picture that being lucky is most often (but not always) a prerequisite to playing poker in the first place.
As a thought experiment, it’s unlikely someone born into extreme poverty in a country most people wouldn’t be able to identify on a map has ever had the luxury of sitting at a poker table.
One could argue that person is genuinely unlucky given that they, just like you and me, didn’t choose where they were born. If they could, they likely would have chosen somewhere with greener pastures.
When one zooms out far enough to grasp the totality of luck, it’s safe to assume that almost all poker players are lucky simply because poker is generally self-selecting for people who have discretionary time and income to partake in leisurely hobbies.
One arrives at this point in life thanks in large part to the system they were born into which afforded them some level of opportunity. These includes but are not limited to basic healthcare (so they don’t die young – 80% of malaria deaths in Africa are from children under 5), receiving an education, being unable to escape a devastating war, dealing with a hyperinflating currency, etc.
In the game of life, these external and random factors are what I call “being dealt a winning hand.”
Half the world lives on less than $7 a day. Fading being born into that reality is tantamount to winning the greatest coinflip in life, yet few see luck that way.
We take good fortune granted because the distribution doesn’t happen equally. Instead, we get huge pockets of the world that are thriving and others are suffering.
We can think of the reality we’re born into like a starting hand in poker. We can’t control the cards we’re dealt. Few are dealt aces, sure, but I’d wager that if you’re reading this, you’d probably agree you weren’t dealt 72o.
There’s always someone with a better starting hand, but it’s a waste of energy to obsess over it. Poker may be zero sum, but life is not. (A great line I first heard from Rafe Furst).
So long as our starting hand is playable, we can still level up and progress through the game.
The difference between a medium strength holding (say T9ss) and the best one (two aces) is a lot smaller in life than on the felt. In poker, one only receives five new cards, but in life, by way of analogy, we receive thousands.
How we choose to play our hand, along with our mindset, habits and perspective determine more of our long term outcome than our original two cards, (again, assuming our starting is relatively playable to begin with).
While much energy is wasted comparing people’s holdings, it seems the optimal strategy is to be aware that every starting hand has both opportunities and vulnerabilities depending on which cards come and how the hand is played.
As is the case in poker and life, when you’re dealt your first two cards, the hand is far from over. In fact, it’s just getting started.
And while it’s true we can’t control the cards we’re dealt, what we have full control over is how we choose to play them.
Action is on you.
– Alec ♠️
P.S. Check out the new content from this week to take your game to the next level.
Using takeaways from my recent private coaching sessions, I share simple strategies and frameworks to give you a leg up vs. the competition.
Whether you’re a business owner or a retiree, these shifts help you move beyond a “social hobby” mindset to achieve a radical improvement in your play.
My reader Chief has achieved financial independence, but feels lost and burnt out. What should he do next? Poker? Travel? Start a business?
Here’s what I told him.
How He Won $78,000 and 1st Place in a Tournament
This simple adjustment helped my client Armando dominate the tournament scene in Florida.
There comes a time in every poker players journey where they hit a crossroads.
When it comes down to it, there are only two paths to choose from.
Here’s how to make the decision.
Join 30,000+ readers and get one lesson each week on risk and decision-making.